I never liked the Turtles much
as a kid, though I watched the show. I couldn’t stand their catchphrases and
annoying cocky attitudes. But then, teenagers were a lot older than I was –
pretty much adults – and I didn’t see that they were meant to be goofy. I just
saw them as overconfident and irritating.
The first live-action films
were also pretty bad, but that’s mostly to do with the fact that they were just
outright poorly-made, poorly-written and poorly-acted. So what about this one?
With the big ugly new designs and attempts to make the concept a little more
serious and gritty for the Dark Knight generation?
Well, actually, it works. Of
course, it’s a stupid, stupid film, but then, it’s a stupid, stupid concept and
that’s part of the charm of it. It’s the story of four pizza-loving ninja
turtles living in a sewer with a giant rat fighting a weird samurai guy in New
York . It’s inherently stupid. But this film actually
does something quite impressive, which is to embrace that stupidity, include
lots of pop-culture references and comedy and dumbness, and yet deliver it
seriously and sincerely. Thus, while of course it remains a stupid, brainless
popcorn action flick, it’s a likeable and enjoyable one.
The film tells the story in a
slightly new way, tying things up in a way that goes a little beyond
coincidence. When New York is
terrorised by the Foot Gang, headed by Shredder, puff-piece news reporter April
O’Neil discovers that some vigilantes have been fighting back. Investigating
them further, she discovers that they are the Ninja Turtles, and after a little
more investigation, realises that by sheer coincidence, they are the very
turtles her own father had created before he died in suspicious circumstances. She
goes to her father’s old lab partner to confirm her suspicions, now a rich and
powerful man, but of course he is not to be trusted. Though it has taken some
ridiculous coincidences to get this far, the rest unfolds quite neatly, with
April’s revelation having set the rest of the film’s action into motion, and
after Shredder’s attack on the turtles’ lair establishes the ticking bomb, the
Turtles have to spring to action to rescue the city, with the help of April and
her creepy but somewhat amusing cameraman. It kinda works, though the bad guy’s
motive to get more rich stumbles over itself in an attempt to have a clever,
modern false flag twist, which doesn’t work because...well, the guy’s already
super-rich.
The turtles are not
detestable. Perhaps they never were. They are actually effectively characterized
as a bunch of kids, quite out-of-keeping with their hulking forms. Michelangelo
has always been goofy, but here has enough self-effacing and idiotic humour for
things to work, Donatello is a bit more of a geek but also a bit more of a
rounded character, Raphael is the powerhouse of the team but has a weak,
vulnerable side, and Leonardo is the boring leader as usual. Shredder is
actually formidable this time – though it was a mistake to cast an
American-born Japanese actor instead of an actual Japanese one, because his
accent speaking Japanese is really bad. I know that their being huge and
scary-looking has put a lot of people off, and maybe gets in the way of them
coming over as teenagers, but the writing is actually pretty good.
Overall, bad film, but fun,
and better than expected. If someone can explain why Splinter has an accent, I’d
like to know!